Is It Time to Let Ripley Retire for Good? The Debate Over Sigourney Weaver's Return to the Alien Universe
Horror Movie Buzz
Published moments ago
Imagine this: the iconic scream queen of sci-fi horror, Sigourney Weaver, hinting at a comeback in the Alien saga. But do we truly want more Ripley, or has her story run its course? At New York Comic Con (https://www.joblo.com/walter-hill-alien-sequel/), Weaver dropped the bombshell that she's been chatting with Disney about potential new adventures in the franchise. Even better—or worse, depending on your view—veteran producer Walter Hill has penned a 50-page outline exploring what Ripley's been up to all these years. This revelation has sparked a frenzy of online chatter, from blog posts to video essays asking, 'Could Ripley really return?' Yet, in an era flooded with underwhelming legacy sequels—those follow-ups that lean heavily on nostalgia from decades-old hits, often disappointing fans with recycled plots—I'm left wondering if bringing her back is the right move. The Alien series is thriving on its own right now, so why risk diluting that momentum?
Look, I have nothing but admiration for Sigourney Weaver and the groundbreaking Ripley she brought to life. She's not just a character; she's a cultural powerhouse who redefined strong female leads in action and horror cinema. (Fun fact: I even named my childhood pet after her, a testament to her lasting charm.) Ripley embodies resilience, facing unimaginable horrors with grit and heart. But after all she's endured, shouldn't we give her a well-deserved break? Think about it: across three main films (or four, if you include the cloned versions in the later entries), she's been relentlessly pursued by the nightmarish Xenomorphs—those acid-blooded, face-hugging extraterrestrials that turn every encounter into a survival nightmare. She's lost colleagues, friends, and even romantic interests to these creatures, time and again. For beginners dipping into the franchise, the Xenomorphs are basically unstoppable killing machines designed by H.R. Giger, blending biomechanical terror with pure instinctual fear. Do we really want to subject Ripley to even more trauma?
And here's where it gets tricky... How on earth would they pull off her resurrection without it feeling forced? We all remember the gut-wrenching finale of Alien 3, where the real, original Ripley sacrifices herself to stop the alien threat from spreading— a poignant end that felt final and earned. Then came Alien: Resurrection, with its clone twist, which some fans loved for its bold weirdness but others saw as a betrayal of that closure. Would a new story pick up from those clones, maybe exploring genetic echoes of Ripley? Or—and this is the controversial part—would they retcon everything after Aliens, pretending Alien 3 and Resurrection never happened? That's exactly what Neill Blomkamp planned for his abandoned Alien 5 project (https://www.joblo.com/neill-blomkamp-shuts-down-question-alien/), a sequel that would have ignored the messy later films to continue directly from the 1986 classic. For newcomers, retconning means rewriting established history in a franchise, which can refresh things but often divides audiences. Neither option thrills me personally; it all smacks of cheap nostalgia bait, designed to lure in old fans rather than innovate.
sponsored content
We've already witnessed a smarter path forward with Alien: Romulus, the recent hit that introduces fresh faces echoing Ripley's toughness—resourceful survivors thrust into the franchise's deadly corporate conspiracies—without relying on legacy stars. This approach lets new stories breathe, building on the universe's core themes of isolation, betrayal by megacorporations like Weyland-Yutani, and human versus alien survival, all while honoring the originals. For example, the film's young protagonists face similar moral dilemmas and physical perils as Ripley did, but they carve their own path, making the horror feel immediate and relatable. Jumping back to Ripley now, post-Romulus, seems like a step backward, especially with the upcoming FX series Alien: Earth humming along successfully on its own, exploring Earth-bound invasions without needing the OG heroine. It strikes me as oddly regressive, almost like ignoring the franchise's evolution.
But this is the part most people miss when debating legacy returns... There's also the elephant in the room: age and practicality. At 76, Weaver brings incredible gravitas—seen in her youthful portrayal via de-aging tech in the Avatar sequels—but action roles demand physicality that might not align with an older Ripley battling Xenomorphs in zero-gravity chases or hand-to-hand combat. Production delays could push filming years out, raising questions about feasibility. I get the nostalgia pull; Ripley is beloved for good reason, a feminist icon who kicked butt in a male-dominated genre. Yet, when does reverence tip into exploitation? Isn't it controversial to keep dragging these icons back, potentially tarnishing their legacy with subpar stories? Let Ripley escape the Weyland-Yutani clutches and the Xenomorph hives for good. We don't need plotlines revealing she's been rotting in cryo-prison or facing some bleak fate these past decades. Instead, allow fans to envision her in retirement, perhaps on a quiet colony world, finally at peace. After all, Walter Hill, who hasn't delivered a standout script in over three decades (https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001353/?ref=nvsrsrsg0tt5nm3in0qwalter%2520hill), might not be the visionary to honor her story anew. It's a counterpoint worth pondering: sometimes, the best sequel is no sequel at all.
So, what’s your take, fellow horror enthusiasts? Do you crave seeing Sigourney Weaver reprise Ripley, or are you team 'let sleeping aliens lie'? How should the Alien franchise evolve next—more prequels, Earth-based tales, or bold new directions? Drop your thoughts in the comments below; I'd love to hear if you agree, disagree, or have wild ideas of your own!
About the Author
Film Critic
Top Picks: Se7en, Halloween, Scream, A Nightmare on Elm Street, Back to the Future, Battle Royale, Jaws, The Social Network, Friday the 13th, American Movie, all things Tarantino, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, Evil Dead, The Batman, The Shining, No Country for Old Men, Terminator 2, Boyhood, Ed Wood, Jurassic Park, Wild at Heart
Passions: Diving into horror flicks, cinema in general, crafting stories, strumming the guitar, the Marvel Cinematic Universe, delightfully terrible films, video games, Spider-Man adventures, a good whiskey, pro wrestling drama, hockey thrills, football excitement, Star Wars lore, plotting world domination (in jest), Jeopardy trivia, and the quiet power of silence
