Most Senate Democrats oppose colleagues' shutdown deal | AP News
The deal struck by some Senate Democrats to reopen the government has reignited internal party tensions, just days after recent election victories had raised hopes for unity among left-wing factions ahead of the 2026 midterms. This discord is not solely between progressives and centrists, but rather a renewed dispute over the strategy to confront President Donald Trump and his Republican allies in Congress. Some progressives are calling for Senate Leader Chuck Schumer's resignation, despite his public opposition to the deal.
The controversy revolves around the deal's failure to guarantee the extension of Affordable Care Act premium subsidies, a key Democratic demand. This has led to accusations that Schumer couldn't maintain unity within his caucus. Some moderates, however, are frustrated by the prolonged shutdown, seeing it as a way to exert influence and achieve policy goals in a Republican-dominated Congress.
Party leaders, including Schumer and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, blame Republicans for the premium spikes and shutdown consequences. Yet, the deal's sudden conclusion highlights the challenges of maintaining a cohesive Democratic coalition. Maurice Mitchell, a progressive leader, warns that Republicans can harm communities, and Democrats may cave under pressure.
New Jersey Governor-elect Mikie Sherrill, a Democratic victor, emphasizes the need for strong leadership, criticizing the Senate's potential surrender. Dealmakers argue there was no viable alternative, as Republicans were unwilling to budge, and the shutdown's impact on low-income Americans and air traffic delays was severe.
Democrats secured a December vote on ACA subsidies and back pay for federal workers, but this didn't satisfy all. Some Senate holdouts, like Michigan's Elissa Slotkin and Georgia's Jon Ossoff, blame Republicans for healthcare issues, despite Trump's refusal to fix them. Mallory McMorrow, a Michigan state senator, criticizes the party's adherence to old rules while Republicans employ brazen tactics, questioning the purpose of their sacrifices.
The deal underscores generational divides within the party. The eight senators involved in the agreement are over 65 and won't face reelection in 2026. This includes 78-year-old Jeanne Shaheen and 80-year-old Dick Durbin, both retiring before the midterms. The age of Democratic leaders and their perceived disconnect from the party's base have been ongoing concerns, with Joe Biden being the oldest president and facing reelection challenges at 82. Yet, Biden and former Speaker Nancy Pelosi, retiring at 85, are credited with significant legislative achievements despite thin Democratic majorities.
Schumer, 74, has faced criticism for not shutting down the government in the spring and for not keeping the caucus united during the latest shutdown. This has sparked calls for his resignation, with some progressives and Senate candidates advocating for a new generation of leaders. The debate over Schumer's leadership and the party's strategy continues, with progressives looking ahead to 2026 and the need for a fighting opposition.
